IN THE HIGH COURT OF SINDH AT KARACHI

 

 

I.A. No.10 OF 2004

[Mirza Sugar Mills Limited (Company) & others v. Sajid Hussain Naqvi & another]

 

 

PRESENT:

            Mr. Justice Arshad Hussain Khan

                                      Mr. Justice Amjad Ali Sahito       

 

 

Appellants                 :           Through Mr. Mukhtar Ahmed Kuber, Advocate.

 

Respondent No.1      :           Through Masood Anwar Ausaf, Advocate.

                                               

Date of hearing         :           03.11.2026

Date of order             :           16.11.2026

 

 

 

JUDGMENT

 

ARSHAD HUSSAIN KHAN J;                   Through this appeal, preferred under Section 22 of the Financial Institutions (Recovery of Finances) Ordinance, 2001 (“the Ordinance”), the Appellants have assailed the judgment and decree dated 10.01.2004, passed by the learned Banking Court No.1, Karachi, in Suit No.483 of 2002, whereby the suit instituted by Respondent No.1 was decreed against the Appellants and other defendants, jointly and severally, for Rs.10,989,795/-, along with costs and cost of funds at the rate of 8% from the date of default, i.e., 01.07.2002.

2.         Briefly, the facts giving rise to the present appeal are that Respondent No.1, Investment Corporation of Pakistan, sanctioned a financial facility of Rs.23,630,000/- in favour of Appellant No.1 under the Locally Manufactured Machinery (LMM) Finance Scheme vide sanction letter dated 17.12.1991, followed by execution of a finance agreement dated 15.07.1992. The facility was secured through mortgage of immovable properties, hypothecation of plant and machinery, floating charge and personal guarantees furnished by the concerned defendants. Against the sanctioned facility, an amount of Rs.18,900,795/- was actually disbursed, repayable over eight years in half-yearly instalments, with markup at the rate of 8% per annum. Alleging default in repayment, Respondent No.1 instituted Suit No.483 of 2002 before the learned Banking Court No.1, Karachi, seeking recovery of Rs.16,274,490/- along with markup and other consequential relief. The contesting defendants filed an application for leave to defend, disputing the outstanding liability and raising an objection regarding limitation. During the proceedings, their counsel expressed willingness to discharge the liability in accordance with the finance agreement through instalments. Consequently, the learned Banking Court dismissed the application for leave to defend and directed submission of a breakup of the outstanding amount in accordance with the agreement, permitting the defendants to participate in the calculation. By the impugned judgment dated 10.01.2004, the learned Banking Court determined the buy-back price at Rs.27,346,007/- and, after adjusting repayments of Rs.16,355,212/-, decreed the suit for Rs.10,989,795/- against defendants Nos.1 to 8, jointly and severally, along with costs and cost of funds at the rate of 8% from the date of default, i.e., 01.07.2002. The decretal amount was directed to be paid in 24 equal monthly instalments of Rs.457,908.12 each. Aggrieved by the determination of the decretal amount, the Appellants have preferred the present appeal, principally disputing the computation of the buy-back price and adjustment of repayments, and seeking reduction of the decretal amount to Rs.8,234,497/-.

3.         Learned counsel for the Appellants, while assailing the impugned judgment and decree, contends that the learned Banking Court erred in determining the outstanding liability at Rs.10,989,795/- by incorrectly computing the proportionate buy-back price and failing to adjust the entire repayments made by Appellant No.1. He submits that although the sanctioned financial facility was Rs.23,630,000/-, only Rs.18,900,795/- was actually disbursed, which fact was acknowledged by Respondent No.1 in its counter-affidavit filed in response to the application for leave to defend. According to learned counsel, the proportionate buy-back price, calculated on the actual disbursement under the finance agreement dated 15.07.1992, worked out to Rs.25,822,110/-, whereas the learned Banking Court erroneously determined the same at Rs.27,346,007/-, resulting in an excess of Rs.1,523,897/-. He further submits that Respondent No.1's own statement of account reflected repayments aggregating to Rs.17,587,613/-, but the learned Banking Court accounted for only Rs.16,355,212/-, thereby failing to adjust a further sum of Rs.1,232,401/-. He maintains that these computational errors resulted in an excessive decretal amount and that, upon proper reconciliation, the outstanding liability would stand reduced to Rs.8,234,497/-. Learned counsel further submits that the Appellants have not disputed their obligation to discharge the amount lawfully outstanding and have already tendered the first instalment of Rs.350,000/- through cheque dated 23.01.2004, demonstrating their willingness to comply with the repayment schedule. He, therefore, prays that the impugned judgment and decree be modified to the extent of reducing the decretal amount from Rs.10,989,795/- to Rs.8,234,497/-, while maintaining the facility of payment in 24 equal instalments.

 

4.         Learned counsel for Respondent No.1, while supporting the impugned judgment and decree, submits that the learned Banking Court correctly determined the outstanding liability of the Appellants on the basis of the finance agreement and statement of account. He contends that although a financial facility of Rs.23,630,000/- was sanctioned, an amount of Rs.18,901,000/- was actually disbursed and availed by Appellant No.1, against which the total buy-back price, inclusive of principal and markup, was Rs.27,346,007/-. After adjusting repayments of Rs.16,356,212/-, the outstanding liability was correctly determined at Rs.10,989,795/-, for which the suit was decreed along with costs and cost of funds at the rate of 8% from 01.07.2002. He further submits that during the pendency of the appeal, the Appellants admitted liability to the extent of Rs.8,234,497/- vide order dated 18.08.2004 and subsequently paid Rs.5,600,000/- between 28.03.2004 and 22.09.2005 and Rs.2,634,493/- on 26.01.2007. He points out that although the parties acknowledged the principal amount disbursed and repayments made, the Appellants' assertion of full and final satisfaction of the decree was disputed by Respondent No.1, which maintained that further amounts remained recoverable towards the decretal liability. He further submits that this Court appointed chartered accountants vide orders dated 26.08.2010 and 08.08.2014 to ascertain the actual outstanding amount; however, the reconciliation exercise could not be undertaken. Referring to the latest statement of account filed pursuant to this Court's order dated 03.11.2026, learned counsel maintains that an amount of Rs.10,379,691/- remained outstanding as of 31.10.2026 in terms of the impugned decree. He, therefore, contends that the payments made during the pendency of the appeal do not establish full satisfaction of the decretal liability and prays that the appeal be dismissed and the impugned judgment and decree be maintained.

5.         We have heard learned counsel for the parties and examined the impugned judgment, the material available on record and the statements filed during the pendency of the appeal. The controversy between the parties is essentially confined to the correctness of the decretal amount and the effect of subsequent payments made by the Appellants. The sanction and disbursement of the financial facility are not disputed, nor is the execution of the finance agreement and the securities furnished thereunder.

6.         In view of the respective submissions, the following questions arise for determination:

(i) Whether the learned Banking Court correctly determined the buy-back price and adjusted the repayments made by the Appellants while passing the impugned decree?

(ii) Whether the payments made during the pendency of the appeal constitute full satisfaction of the decretal liability, or whether any further amount remains recoverable by Respondent No.1?

(iii) Whether the impugned judgment and decree call for interference in appellate jurisdiction?

 

7.         As regards the first question, the record reflects that the sanctioned financial facility was Rs.23,630,000/-, whereas the amount actually disbursed was approximately Rs.18.901 million. The learned Banking Court determined the buy-back price at Rs.27,346,007/- and, after adjusting repayments of Rs.16,355,212/-, arrived at an outstanding balance of Rs.10,989,795/-. The Appellants, however, maintain that the proportionate buy-back price ought to have been Rs.25,822,110/- and that further repayments were not accounted for. It is significant that the dispute does not concern the existence of the financial obligation but its correct quantification. The learned Banking Court was, therefore, required to determine the outstanding liability strictly in accordance with the finance agreement, the actual disbursement and the payments established through the statement of account.

8.         The Appellants' contention regarding the proportionate buy-back price cannot be rejected merely on the ground that their application for leave to defend had been dismissed. The finance agreement originally contemplated a sanctioned facility of Rs.23,630,000/-, whereas the actual disbursement was substantially less. Whether the contractual buy-back price stood proportionately reduced, and to what extent, depended upon the terms of the agreement and the agreed repayment schedule. The impugned judgment, however, does not disclose the calculation by which the buy-back price of Rs.27,346,007/- was arrived at. Similarly, the judgment does not explain the basis upon which the total repayments were determined at Rs.16,355,212/-, particularly when the Appellants disputed that figure by reference to Respondent No.1's own statement of account. In the absence of a clear reconciliation of these figures, the determination of the decretal amount cannot be regarded as free from doubt.

9.         The subsequent proceedings before this Court assume considerable significance. The record, as reflected in the statement filed by Respondent No.1, indicates that vide order dated 18.08.2004, the Appellants admitted liability to the extent of Rs.8,234,497/-. It is further stated that payments aggregating to approximately that amount were subsequently made during the pendency of the appeal. More importantly, the parties, vide order dated 19.05.2006, reportedly acknowledged that the principal amount disbursed was Rs.18,901,000/-, against which repayments of Rs.17,587,613/- had been made, leaving a balance of Rs.1,313,182/-, which was also stated to have been paid subsequently. These developments establish that substantial payments were made after the impugned decree and that the accounts between the parties underwent material changes during the pendency of the appeal.

10.       Nevertheless, the Appellants' assertion that the entire decretal liability stood discharged cannot be accepted solely on the basis of payment of the amount admitted by them. An admission of liability to a particular extent does not, by itself, establish that no further amount is legally recoverable. Equally, Respondent No.1 cannot claim further recovery merely by submitting a revised statement of account without demonstrating the contractual and legal basis of the amount claimed and giving due credit for all payments received. The question of satisfaction of the decree must be determined upon reconciliation of the accounts, keeping in view the contractual obligations, the decretal amount and the payments made during the pendency of the appeal.

11.       Respondent No.1 has now claimed Rs.10,379,691/- as outstanding on 31.10.2026. However, the statement placed before this Court does not, by itself, establish the correctness of that amount. The original decree was for Rs.10,989,795/-, together with costs and cost of funds at 8% from 01.07.2002. Substantial payments were admittedly received thereafter. It is, therefore, necessary to ascertain the dates and amounts of such payments, their proper appropriation and the basis upon which the remaining liability has been calculated. In particular, any computation of cost of funds must conform to the decree and the applicable statutory provisions, and no amount already discharged can be recovered again.

12.       It is also relevant that this Court, having regard to the disputed calculations, appointed M/s Afzal Muneer & Co., Chartered Accountants, vide order dated 26.08.2010, to ascertain the amount due and payable. Upon their inability to undertake the exercise, M/s Muniff Ziauddin Junaidy & Co., Chartered Accountants, were appointed vide order dated 08.08.2014. However, the proposed reconciliation was not completed. The fact that independent reconciliation was considered necessary during the appellate proceedings reinforces the conclusion that the dispute regarding the outstanding amount requires examination of the underlying accounts rather than acceptance of either party's unilateral computation.

13.       At the same time, the distinction between the correctness of the original decree and its subsequent satisfaction must be maintained. The legality of the impugned decree is to be examined with reference to the contractual documents and the liability existing when the decree was passed. Payments made thereafter are relevant to the extent of satisfaction of the decree but do not, by themselves, establish that the original determination was erroneous. Conversely, the continued assertion of an outstanding balance by Respondent No.1 cannot cure any computational error in the impugned judgment.

14.       Upon examining the impugned judgment, we find that although the learned Banking Court recorded the principal amount disbursed, the buy-back price and the repayments, it did not set out a sufficiently clear basis for determining the disputed figures. The Appellants have specifically identified differences in the calculation of the buy-back price and the adjustment of repayments. These objections relate directly to the quantum of liability and cannot be dismissed as immaterial. However, the available record also does not justify acceptance of the Appellants' proposed figure of Rs.8,234,497/- as the final contractual liability without verification of the relevant calculations. Accordingly, neither the Appellants' computation nor the subsequent outstanding balance claimed by Respondent No.1 can be conclusively adopted on the present material.

15.       In these circumstances, we are of the view that the appropriate course is to preserve the undisputed financial obligation and the payments already made, while directing determination of the disputed amount through proper reconciliation. Such an exercise must remain confined to the existing finance agreement, the statements of account and the documentary material already forming part of the record, together with the payments made pursuant to orders passed during the pendency of the appeal. It shall not permit reopening of the underlying transaction or introduction of any new claim beyond the scope of the original decree.

16.       For the foregoing reasons, the appeal is partly allowed. The impugned judgment and decree dated 10.01.2004 are set aside only to the extent of determination of the outstanding amount, while the finding regarding the Appellants' liability under the finance agreement is maintained. The matter is remitted to the learned Banking Court concerned for the limited purpose of determining the amount, if any, legally recoverable by Respondent No.1, after verifying the buy-back price in accordance with the finance agreement, adjusting all established repayments, including those made during the pendency of the appeal, and calculating the permissible costs and cost of funds without duplication. The exercise shall be confined to the existing documentary record, without recording fresh evidence or permitting either party to enlarge the scope of its original claim or defence.

JUDGE

JUDGE

 

 

 

Naveed PA