IN THE HIGH COURT OF SINDH AT KARACHI

 

H.C.A. No.370 of 2023

[ Saeed Ahmed Qazi v. Muhammad Sohail ]

 

 

 

PRESENT:

            Mr. Justice Arshad Hussain Khan

                                     Mr. Justice Amjad Ali Sahito       

 

Appellant                               :         Through Mr. Basil Nabi Malik, Advocate.

 

Respondent No.1 & 3          :           Nemo.

 

Respondents No.                  :           Through M/s. Naseer Ahmed and

Rehmat-un-Nisa, Advocates.

 

Date of hearing                     :           13.11.2026

 

Date of Decision                  :           13.11.2026

 

 

 

JUDGMENT

 

ARSHAD HUSSAIN KHAN J;                   This High Court Appeal, filed under Section 15 of the Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Ordinance, 1980 (Ordinance X of 1980), is directed against the order dated 21.09.2023 passed by the learned Single Judge, exercising original civil jurisdiction, in Suit No.2469 of 2015, whereby the Appellant’s application under Order I Rule 10 CPC (CMA No.3011 of 2023), seeking to be joined as a party to the suit, was dismissed.”

2.         The relevant facts, briefly stated, are that the Appellant claims ownership of Plot No.C-2/2/1, Sector-1, Scheme No.35, Lines Area Re-Development Project (LARP), Karachi, measuring 800 square yards, on the basis of a transfer letter dated 12.03.2021 and paid challan. According to the Appellant, the plot was originally allotted to Anwar Hussain on 10.01.2014, subsequently transferred to Sharafat Ali, from whom he acquired it. He further relies upon the approved site plan, verification letter dated 30.03.2021 issued by Respondent No.3, and the written statement filed by the said Respondent in Suit No.646 of 2021, acknowledging his ownership and possession. Respondent No.1 instituted Suit No.2469 of 2015 for declaration, permanent injunction and damages against KDA and the Project Director, LARP, followed by Suit Nos.1483 and 1484 of 2016 and Suit No.646 of 2021, wherein the Appellant is arrayed as Defendant No.5. All four suits have been consolidated and are pending adjudication. The Appellant maintains that Respondent No.1 is asserting rights over the same property and that the interim injunction dated 15.12.2015 passed in Suit No.2469 of 2015 affects his interests. The Appellant had also instituted C.P. No.D-2288 of 2021, which was dismissed on 24.01.2023, while C.P. No.D-979 of 2022, challenging an order passed in proceedings before the Provincial Ombudsman, remains pending. Claiming to be a necessary and proper party to Suit No.2469 of 2015, the Appellant filed an application under Order I Rule 10 CPC (CMA No.3011 of 2023), seeking to be joined as a party to the suit. The application was contested by Respondent No.1 and dismissed by the learned Single Judge through the impugned order dated 21.09.2023, giving rise to the present Appeal.

3.         Learned counsel for the Appellant, while assailing the impugned order, contended that the learned Single Judge failed to appreciate the material available on record, particularly the documents and written statements filed by Respondents No.2 and 3, establishing that Plot No.C-2/1/4, Sector-1, LARP, measuring 1300 square yards, claimed by Respondent No.1, does not exist. In support of his contention, he referred to the letter dated 09.01.2015 issued by Respondent No.3, whereby the allotment, site plan and possession documents relating to the said plot were cancelled on account of alleged concealment of facts and fabricated documents, as well as the letter dated 10.02.2021 issued by the Deputy Director (C&S), LARP, KDA, confirming that the said plot does not exist in the approved master plan. He further relied upon the written statement of Respondent No.2, wherein the existence of the said plot and any auction proceedings relating thereto were denied. Learned counsel maintained that Respondent No.1, under the guise of claiming the aforesaid nonexistent plot, is attempting to assert rights over Plot No.C-2/2/1, lawfully acquired by the Appellant. He argued that the controversy essentially concerns the same property and that the Appellant's presence is necessary for the effective and complete adjudication of the dispute. According to him, the learned Single Judge dismissed the application on technical grounds without examining the material controversy, thereby denying the Appellant an opportunity of hearing and violating the principles of natural justice. He, therefore, prayed that the Appeal be allowed, the impugned order be set aside and the Appellant be joined as a defendant in Suit No.2469 of 2015.

4.         Learned counsel for KDA, appearing for Respondents No. 2, submitted that he has no objection if the appellant is impleaded as a party to the proceedings.    

5.         The present Appeal was instituted on 11.10.2023. Record reflects that Respondents No.1 and 3 were served with notices under Order XLIII Rule 3 CPC prior to its institution (Annexures P/22 to P/24). Despite issuance of repeated notices thereafter, none has appeared on their behalf. Since the matter has remained pending for a considerable period, further adjournment on account of their continued non-appearance would serve no useful purpose. Accordingly, this Court deems it appropriate to proceed with the Appeal on the basis of the available record and with the assistance of learned counsel for the Appellant and Respondent No.2 (KDA), without granting any further opportunity.

6.         We have heard learned counsel for the Appellant and Respondent No.2 (KDA) and examined the available record with their assistance.

7.         The principal question requiring determination is whether the learned Single Judge was justified in dismissing the Appellant’s application under Order I Rule 10 CPC on the ground that the property claimed by him was distinct from the subject matter of the suit.

8.         The learned Single Judge, while dismissing the application, observed that Suit No.2469 of 2015 concerned Plot No.C-2/1/4, measuring 1300 square yards, whereas the Appellant claimed ownership of Plot No.C-2/2/1, measuring 800 square yards. On the basis of the difference in plot numbers, descriptions and areas, the learned Single Judge concluded that, prima facie, the properties were distinct and that no material had been placed on record establishing any correlation between them.

9.         We are, with respect, unable to endorse the aforesaid conclusion in view of the pleadings available on record. The Appellant specifically asserted in his application that Plot No.C-2/1/4, claimed by Respondent No.1, did not exist and that Respondent No.1 was attempting to assert rights over Plot No.C-2/2/1 belonging to the Appellant. Significantly, Respondent No.1, in paragraph 11 of his counter-affidavit, himself alleged that the Appellant's allotment of 800 square yards had been carved out of the property claimed by him and that the original site plan had been manipulated by the LARP authorities to facilitate such allotment. In paragraph 19, Respondent No.1 further alleged that the concerned authorities had created a fictitious plot upon the property claimed by him. These assertions demonstrate that Respondent No.1 himself disputes the Appellant's claim to the very land forming the subject matter of the suit. Thus, notwithstanding the difference in plot numbers and areas, the pleadings disclose a direct controversy concerning the identity, location and competing claims over the property, which the impugned order failed to appreciate.

10.       The documentary material available on record further reinforces the existence of such controversy. The letters dated 09.01.2015 and 10.02.2021 issued by the concerned LARP authorities indicate that the allotment relating to Plot No.C-2/1/4 had been cancelled and that the said plot was not reflected in the approved master plan. Conversely, the letter dated 30.03.2021 and the written statement filed by the concerned authority in Suit No.646 of 2021 acknowledge the Appellant's claim in respect of Plot No.C-2/2/1. Respondent No.2 (KDA) has also disputed the existence of Plot No.C-2/1/4 and the alleged auction proceedings relating thereto. While these documents do not conclusively establish the rights of either party, they demonstrate that the controversy cannot appropriately be resolved merely by treating the two plots as distinct on account of their different descriptions.

11.       Under Order I Rule 10(2) CPC, the Court is empowered, at any stage of the proceedings, to add a person whose presence is necessary to enable it to effectually and completely adjudicate upon and settle the questions involved in the suit. The determination of such an application does not require adjudication of the applicant's title or proprietary rights. What is material is whether his presence is necessary or proper for the effective resolution of the controversy. In the present case, the competing pleadings disclose a substantial dispute concerning the identity and location of the land claimed by the respective parties. Any adjudication concerning the existence, location or entitlement to the disputed property may directly affect the Appellant's asserted rights. His presence is, therefore, necessary to ensure that the controversy is determined after affording an opportunity of hearing to all persons directly concerned.

12.       It is also significant that the Appellant is already arrayed as Defendant No.5 in Suit No.646 of 2021, which, along with Suit Nos.2469 of 2015, 1483 of 2016 and 1484 of 2016, has been consolidated for adjudication. In these circumstances, his addition as a defendant in Suit No.2469 of 2015 would facilitate the complete determination of the controversy and minimise the possibility of inconsistent findings. No procedural prejudice would be caused to Respondent No.1, who would remain entitled to contest the Appellant's claim in accordance with law. Learned counsel for Respondent No.2 (KDA) has also raised no objection to the Appellant being joined as a defendant.

13.       In view of the foregoing, we are satisfied that the learned Single Judge failed to appreciate the material averments contained in Respondent No.1's own counter-affidavit, which disclose a direct nexus between the properties claimed by the respective parties. The Appellant is, therefore, a necessary and proper party for the effective and complete adjudication of the controversy. Consequently, the impugned order cannot be sustained. It is, however, clarified that the observations made herein are confined exclusively to the determination of the application under Order I Rule 10 CPC and shall not be construed as findings regarding the existence, location, ownership or entitlement to either of the disputed plots, which questions shall be determined independently by the learned Trial Court on the basis of the evidence and applicable law.

14.       Before parting with the matter, it may be observed that, during the pendency of the present Appeal, the Sindh Civil Courts Ordinance, 1962, was amended through the Sindh Civil Courts (Amendment) Act, 2025 (Sindh Act No.VI of 2025), whereby the pecuniary jurisdiction of the District Judge in civil suits and proceedings was enhanced without monetary limitation. Section 7-A, inserted through the said amendment, also provides for the transfer of suits and proceedings pending before this Court in its original civil jurisdiction to the Courts of the concerned District Judges. The underlying suit, along with the connected suits, has since been transferred to the Court of the competent Senior Civil Judge, Karachi (East), for further proceedings in accordance with law.

15.       Accordingly, the present Appeal is allowed. The impugned order dated 21.09.2023 is set aside and CMA No.3011 of 2023, filed by the Appellant under Order I Rule 10 CPC in Suit No.2469 of 2015, is allowed. The Appellant shall be joined as a defendant in the said suit. The learned Trial Court shall ensure that the title of the suit is amended accordingly and shall afford the Appellant an opportunity to file his written statement within such time as may be fixed by it. The suit, along with the connected suits, shall thereafter be proceeded in accordance with law, uninfluenced by any observations made herein concerning the merits of the respective claims.

 

                                                                                                            JUDGE

JUDGE

 

 

 

Naveed PA