IN THE HIGH COURT OF SINDH, KARACHI
Ist Appeal No.41 of 2004
[ S.M. Traders & others v. Bank Al-Falah Limited ]
Ist Appeal No.61 of 2004
[ Bank Al-Falah Limited v. S.M. Traders & others ]
PRESENT:
Mr. Justice Arshad Hussain Khan
Mr. Justice Amjad Ali Sahito
Mr. Shaheer A. Shaikh, advocate for Appellants in IA No.41 of 2004 and for respondents in IA No.61 of 2004.
M/s. Tariq A. Memon and Abdul Munam, advocates for appellant in IA No.61 of 2004 and for respondent in IA No.41 of 2004
Date of hearing : 27.10.2026
Date of Decision : 11.11.2026
JUDGMENT
ARSHAD HUSSAIN KHAN, J: These two High Court Appeals, filed under Section 22 of the Financial Institutions (Recovery of Finances) Ordinance, 2001 (“the Ordinance”), arise out of the common judgment and decree dated 04.03.2004 passed by the learned Banking Court No.I, Karachi, in consolidated Suit Nos.666 and 1024 of 1997, whereby both suits were dismissed without any order as to costs. Suit No.666 of 1997 was instituted by Bank Alfalah Limited against M/s. S.M. Traders and others for recovery of Rs.8,507,151.02, whereas Suit No.1024 of 1997 was instituted by M/s. S.M. Traders and others against the Bank for recovery of the unpaid export proceeds, along with declaration, cancellation of documents and damages. Aggrieved by dismissal of their respective suits, M/s. S.M. Traders and others preferred HCA No.41 of 2004, while Bank Alfalah Limited preferred HCA No.61 of 2004. Since both appeals arise from the same transactions and involve interconnected questions of law and fact, they are being decided through this common judgment.
2. Briefly, the facts are that, in 1991, the Dhaka and Chittagong branches of Bank of Credit and Commerce International (Overseas) Limited (“BCCI”) issued irrevocable letters of credit in favour of M/s. S.M. Traders against export orders placed by importers in Bangladesh. BCCI Karachi extended six post-shipment export refinance facilities aggregating to Rs.5,995,000/- under the State Bank of Pakistan Export Finance Scheme, against execution of financing agreements, undertakings, demand promissory notes and letters of hypothecation. Although the export documents were forwarded to the issuing branches and the bills were accepted, the proceeds remained unrealized following the collapse of BCCI in July 1991. Bank Alfalah Limited, claiming to be successor-in-interest of BCCI Karachi under the Scheme of Amalgamation, instituted Suit No.666 of 1997 for recovery of the outstanding finance. Conversely, M/s. S.M. Traders and others, while admitting receipt of the finance and execution of the relevant documents, disputed their liability and instituted Suit No.1024 of 1997, claiming payment in respect of two export bills amounting to US$22,781.24 and US$17,002.53, together with ancillary relief.
3. The learned Banking Court, after recording evidence, principally held that BCCI Karachi had acted as the negotiating bank and that the export bills had been purchased rather than merely forwarded for collection. It further held that, in the absence of noting, protest and notice of dishonour, the exporters stood discharged from liability. The Bank's recovery claim was also rejected on the ground that the disputed advances constituted excluded assets under the Scheme of Amalgamation. As regards the exporters' suit, the learned Banking Court declined their claim for unpaid invoices on the ground of laches, refused cancellation of the security documents and rejected the claim for damages for want of proof. Consequently, both suits were dismissed.
4. Learned counsel for M/s. S.M. Traders and others, appearing as Appellants in HCA No.41 of 2004 and Respondents in HCA No.61 of 2004, contends that BCCI Karachi acted as the negotiating bank, as established by the covering letters, correspondence dated 26.11.1991 and admissions of the Bank's witness. He submits that the exporters had fulfilled their contractual obligations by effecting shipments and submitting the requisite documents, whereas the Bank failed to realize the proceeds, protest the dishonoured bills or return the original documents. He further maintains that BCCI Karachi and its Dhaka and Chittagong branches constituted one legal entity under UCP 400 and that the disputed advances were excluded from the assets transferred under the Scheme of Amalgamation. He also challenges dismissal of the exporters' suit on the ground of laches and refusal to cancel the security documents and award damages. He accordingly seeks allowance of HCA No.41 of 2004 and dismissal of HCA No.61 of 2004.
5. Learned counsel for Bank Alfalah Limited, appearing as Appellant in HCA No.61 of 2004 and Respondent in HCA No.41 of 2004, contends that the transactions constituted independent post-shipment export refinance facilities under the State Bank of Pakistan Export Finance Scheme and not an outright purchase of export bills. He submits that the exporters admittedly received the finance and executed financing agreements, promissory notes and undertakings expressly obligating them to repay the amounts advanced within the stipulated period, irrespective of realization of export proceeds. Referring to the contractual documents, admissions of the exporters' witness and minutes of the meeting held at the State Bank of Pakistan on 27.09.1997, he maintains that the bills were forwarded for collection and that the Bank was under no obligation to protest them in the absence of specific instructions or an applicable legal requirement. He further submits that the advances were not excluded under the Scheme of Amalgamation and places reliance upon Shaukat and Raza (Private) Ltd. and others v. Habib Credit and Exchange Bank Ltd. [PLD 1998 Karachi 36]. He accordingly seeks allowance of HCA No.61 of 2004 and dismissal of HCA No.41 of 2004.
6. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and examined the impugned judgment and material available on record. The principal questions requiring determination are whether the exporters' liability under the financing agreements stood extinguished upon non-payment of the export bills, whether Bank Alfalah Limited acquired the right to recover the disputed advances under the Scheme of Amalgamation and whether the exporters independently established their entitlement to the relief claimed in Suit No.1024 of 1997.
7. At the outset, it is necessary to distinguish between liability arising upon a negotiable instrument and liability arising under an independent financing agreement. The former is governed by the provisions of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, relating to presentment, dishonour, notice and protest, wherever applicable. The latter must be determined in accordance with the terms of the contract and the law governing its enforcement. Merely because finance was extended against export bills does not necessarily mean that the Bank's remedy was confined to proceedings upon those bills. Equally, the description of the Bank as a negotiating or collecting bank does not, by itself, determine whether the exporter had undertaken an independent obligation to repay the finance.
8. In the present case, receipt of Rs.5,995,000/- under the Export Finance Scheme and execution of the financing documents are admitted. The agreements and undertakings, particularly the provisions relating to repayment within the stipulated period and appropriation of export proceeds towards liquidation of the finance, were therefore material to the determination of liability. The learned Banking Court, however, principally proceeded on the basis that BCCI Karachi had negotiated the bills and that its failure to protest them discharged the exporters. In doing so, it failed to adequately examine whether the repayment obligation under the financing agreements was conditional upon actual realization of the export proceeds. The fact that the documents were negotiated or forwarded for collection did not dispense with the necessity of determining the legal effect of the separate contractual undertakings.
9. Sections 93 and 98 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, regulate notice of dishonour and circumstances in which such notice is dispensed with, while Section 104 concerns protest of foreign bills where required by the law of the place where they are drawn. The learned Banking Court, without determining the applicable requirements or their relationship with the financing agreements, treated the absence of protest and notice as sufficient to extinguish the Bank's recovery claim. Its reliance upon Section 51 of the English Bills of Exchange Act, 1882, without establishing its applicability to the transactions, was likewise insufficient. Even where non-compliance with the requirements governing negotiable instruments affects recourse against the drawer, it does not necessarily extinguish an independent contractual obligation, unless such consequence follows from the agreement or applicable law. The impugned finding, therefore, rests upon an incomplete appreciation of the legal position.
10. The finding concerning exclusion of the advances under the Scheme of Amalgamation is also open to exception. Article 1.6 excludes only those assets specifically identified in Part IV of the Schedule. The learned Banking Court inferred exclusion principally from the absence of the exporters' names from the schedule of transferred assets, without adequately determining whether the disputed finance fell within the particular category of excluded advances. In Shaukat and Raza (Private) Ltd. (supra), this Court recognized the effect of the Scheme upon the rights and liabilities of the Pakistani branches of BCCI and their successor. Although the said authority does not conclusively determine the classification of the present advances, the question of succession was required to be resolved by examining the relevant provisions and schedules of the Scheme read with the nature of the transactions. The finding that the Bank lacked entitlement to sue, as presently recorded, cannot therefore be maintained.
11. As regards HCA No.41 of 2004, the exporters' claim for the two unpaid invoices rests upon the assertion that BCCI Karachi and its Dhaka and Chittagong branches constituted one legal entity and that the successor Bank consequently became liable for payment under the letters of credit. However, the fact that the branches originally belonged to the same banking institution does not, by itself, establish that the obligations of the issuing branches were transferred to Bank Alfalah Limited under the Scheme of Amalgamation. The exporters were required to establish an enforceable obligation against the Respondent-Bank, independently of the liability of the issuing branches, and to prove that the amounts claimed remained payable by it. The material discussed in the impugned judgment does not establish such liability. Likewise, the prayer for cancellation of the financing documents could not succeed merely because the Bank's recovery suit had been dismissed, particularly when the underlying contractual liability remained disputed. The claim for damages for alleged defamation was also unsupported by sufficient evidence establishing actionable publication and resulting injury. Although the learned Banking Court's reliance upon laches as the principal ground for rejecting the monetary claim was not satisfactory, the exporters have failed to establish their entitlement to the relief sought. Consequently, dismissal of Suit No.1024 of 1997 does not call for interference.
12. In view of the foregoing discussion, we are of the considered opinion that the learned Banking Court misdirected itself in dismissing Suit No.666 of 1997 without properly determining the independent contractual obligations of the exporters and the Bank's entitlement under the Scheme of Amalgamation. However, an outright decree for the amount claimed would not be justified without determination of the outstanding liability, permissible markup and adjustments, if any, on the basis of the evidence already recorded. The appropriate course is therefore to remit the recovery suit for limited reconsideration, without reopening the evidence or permitting the parties to introduce a new case.
13. Accordingly, HCA No.61 of 2004 is partly allowed. The impugned judgment and decree dated 04.03.2004, insofar as they relate to Suit No.666 of 1997, are set aside, and the said suit is remanded to the concerned Banking Court for fresh determination strictly on the basis of the evidence already recorded. Upon remand, the Banking Court shall determine whether the financing agreements and undertakings created an enforceable obligation to repay the finance independently of realization of the export proceeds; whether the disputed advances were transferred to Bank Alfalah Limited under the Scheme of Amalgamation; and the amount, if any, legally recoverable after giving credit for all proved payments and adjustments, together with such markup or charges as may be permissible under the contractual terms and applicable law. The legal findings recorded herein shall remain binding upon remand. No further evidence shall be recorded, and the parties shall be afforded an opportunity of hearing on the existing record. Having regard to the age of the matter, the Banking Court shall endeavour to decide the suit within three (03) months from receipt of the record.
14. HCA No.41 of 2004 is dismissed, and the judgment and decree dated 04.03.2004, insofar as they relate to Suit No.1024 of 1997, are maintained for the reasons recorded herein. However, any observation in the impugned judgment describing M/s. S.M. Traders and others as defaulters shall not be construed as a final determination of their liability, which remains subject to adjudication in the remanded recovery suit. There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
JUDGE
Naveed PA