IN THE HIGH COURT OF SINDH, KARACHI

 

Ist Appeal No.84  of 2004

[ Habib Bank AG Zurich v. Muhammad Saleem ]

 

 

 

            PRESENT:

            Mr. Justice Arshad Hussain Khan

                                           Mr. Justice Amjad Ali Sahito

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

None present for Appellant

M/s. Tariq A. Memon and Abdul Munam, advocate for respondent

 

 

Date of hearing         :           27.10.2026

Date of Decision      :           11.11.2026

 

JUDGMENT

 

ARSHAD HUSSAIN KHAN, J:                  Through this First Appeal under Section 22 of the Financial Institutions (Recovery of Finances) Ordinance, 2001 (“the Ordinance”), the Appellant, Habib Bank AG Zurich, has challenged the judgment and decree dated 07.06.2004 passed by the learned Banking Court No.I, Karachi, in Suit No.366 of 2001, whereby its suit for recovery of Rs.13,572,406/- along with contractual markup was dismissed.

2.         Briefly, the facts are that, in 1998, the Respondent, Muhammad Saleem, carrying on business as M/s. Musaib Fashions, exported eight consignments of fabrics to M/s. Prestige Apparel Industries, Doha, Qatar, against letters of credit issued by Al Ahli Bank of Qatar and Doha Bank. The Appellant-Bank negotiated the export documents and advanced an aggregate amount of Rs.9,612,964/- against execution of eight Buy-Back-Cum-Indemnities, whereby the Respondent allegedly undertook to repay the negotiated amounts together with agreed markup in the event of non-payment. Although the bills were accepted by the foreign importer, payment was not received. The importer subsequently initiated proceedings in Qatar concerning the quality of the goods and obtained orders restraining remittance under the letters of credit. The Bank's application for impleadment in those proceedings was rejected. Consequently, the Bank instituted the recovery suit on the strength of the aforesaid indemnities.

3.         The Respondent contested the suit, principally maintaining that the Bank had purchased and negotiated the export documents without reservation and that, upon acceptance of the bills by the importer, the responsibility for realization of the proceeds rested with the negotiating Bank. It was further asserted that the indemnities were obtained on standard printed forms, that the documents presented under the letters of credit contained no discrepancies, and that the Bank neither protested the dishonoured bills nor returned the original documents. The Respondent also disputed the statement of account and claimed that the Bank had withheld part of the negotiated value. The learned Banking Court, after recording evidence, held that the Bank, being the negotiating bank, could not recover the amount without returning the original bills duly protested for dishonour. It further held that the Buy-Back-Cum-Indemnities could not be enforced without delivery of the documents to the Respondent. Consequently, the suit was dismissed.

4.         None appeared on behalf of the Appellant-Bank at the time of hearing. However, as reflected in the memo of appeal, the Appellant challenges the impugned judgment principally on the ground that the learned Banking Court failed to appreciate the independent contractual liability arising under the eight Buy-Back-Cum-Indemnities. According to the Appellant, the Respondent had expressly undertaken to repay the amounts advanced together with agreed markup in the event of non-payment by the importer or issuing banks and had waived notice of dishonour. It is maintained that the suit was founded upon the contractual indemnities rather than the bills of exchange themselves and that non-production of the original bills, absence of protest or failure to give notice of dishonour could not defeat the Bank's claim. The Appellant further relies upon Section 98 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, and contended that the proceedings in Qatar did not extinguish its independent contractual remedy against the Respondent. Accordingly, it seeks setting aside of the impugned judgment and decree and decreeing of its suit with costs.

5.         Learned counsel for the Respondent supported the impugned judgment and prayed for dismissal of the appeal.

6.         We have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the Respondent, examined the grounds urged in the memo of appeal and carefully perused the impugned judgment and material available on record. The controversy essentially concerns the legal effect of the Buy-Back-Cum-Indemnities and whether the learned Banking Court was justified in dismissing the recovery suit solely on account of non-compliance with the requirements relating to dishonoured bills of exchange.

7.         It is an established principle that liability arising upon a negotiable instrument is distinct from liability arising under an independent contractual undertaking. While recourse against the drawer or indorser of a dishonoured bill is governed by the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, an express indemnity or repayment agreement must be construed according to its own terms. The existence of a bill of exchange does not necessarily exclude an independent contractual remedy, nor does discharge from liability upon the instrument invariably extinguish obligations separately undertaken under an enforceable agreement. Whether such obligations survive must be determined from the language of the contract and the applicable law.

8.         In the present case, the Bank produced eight Buy-Back-Cum-Indemnities, exhibited as P-3 to P-10, which formed the foundation of its recovery claim. The learned Banking Court itself reproduced portions of these instruments acknowledging negotiation of the documents and their repurchase at the stipulated amount together with charges and markup. However, instead of determining the precise legal effect of these provisions, including the circumstances in which the Respondent's repayment obligation arose, the learned Banking Court proceeded on the premise that the Bank could not recover any amount without first returning the original bills. Such conclusion could not properly be reached without examining whether delivery of the documents was an express condition precedent to repayment, whether the obligation was one of indemnity against non-payment or whether the contractual arrangement contemplated simultaneous performance by the parties. The mere absence of the original bills, therefore, was not by itself sufficient to reject the contractual claim.

9.         The learned Banking Court also placed considerable reliance upon the absence of protest and notice of dishonour. Under Section 98 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, notice of dishonour is dispensed with in circumstances recognized by law, including where the party entitled to notice has waived it. Section 104 further provides that foreign bills must be protested where such protest is required by the law of the place where they are drawn. The learned Banking Court, however, relied upon Section 51 of the English Bills of Exchange Act, 1882, without determining its applicability to the transactions or examining the effect of the alleged contractual waiver. Even where failure to comply with the statutory requirements affects liability upon a negotiable instrument, it does not necessarily defeat an independent contractual claim. The finding that the Respondent stood discharged merely because the bills had not been protested or notice of dishonour had not been given, therefore, cannot be sustained without examination of the relevant contractual provisions.

10.       The learned Banking Court further held that the Bank's only remedy was to proceed against the foreign importer and issuing banks in Qatar. This approach overlooks the distinction between the issuing banks' obligations under the letters of credit and the exporter's obligations under the Buy-Back-Cum-Indemnities. The availability or pursuit of a remedy against the issuing banks does not, by itself, extinguish an independent contractual right against the exporter. Nevertheless, the Bank cannot obtain double recovery, and any amount realized from the importer or issuing banks must necessarily be credited against the liability, if any, established against the Respondent. The existence of proceedings in Qatar was therefore relevant to the question of adjustment and satisfaction of the claim, but could not alone justify dismissal of the recovery suit.

11.       At the same time, the execution of the indemnities and advancement of Rs.9,612,964/- did not automatically entitle the Bank to a decree for the entire amount claimed. The Respondent had disputed the circumstances in which the indemnities were executed, the applicability of their terms, the alleged withholding of part of the negotiated value and the correctness of the statement of account. The Bank's witness also acknowledged that a margin had been retained and that a certified statement of account had not been produced. These matters required examination for determining the extent of liability and the amount legally recoverable, including permissible markup. The learned Banking Court, having dismissed the suit principally on the grounds relating to negotiable instruments, did not adequately determine these questions. Consequently, while the legal basis of dismissal cannot be maintained, an outright decree for the entire amount claimed would not be justified on the findings presently recorded.

12.       In view of the foregoing discussion, we are of the considered opinion that the learned Banking Court failed to properly distinguish between liability arising upon the dishonoured bills and the contractual obligations allegedly undertaken under the Buy-Back-Cum-Indemnities. Its conclusion that non-return of the original bills and absence of protest necessarily extinguished the Bank's right of recovery was legally unsustainable without examination of the terms and enforceability of the indemnities. However, determination of the Respondent's contractual liability and the amount, if any, recoverable requires consideration of the evidence already recorded. Since these material questions were not adequately adjudicated, the appropriate course is to remit the matter for limited reconsideration.

13.       Accordingly, this Appeal is partly allowed. The impugned judgment and decree dated 07.06.2004 passed in Suit No.366 of 2001 are set aside, and the suit is remanded to the concerned Banking Court for fresh determination strictly on the basis of the evidence already recorded. Upon remand, the Banking Court shall determine whether the Buy-Back-Cum-Indemnities created an enforceable contractual obligation upon the Respondent independently of liability under the bills of exchange; whether the contractual conditions for enforcement, including any obligation concerning return of the documents, were fulfilled or otherwise dispensed with; and the amount, if any, legally recoverable after allowing all proved payments, retained margins and adjustments, together with such markup or charges as may be permissible under the contractual terms and applicable law. The legal findings recorded herein concerning the distinction between contractual liability and liability upon negotiable instruments shall remain binding upon remand. No further evidence shall be recorded, and the parties shall be afforded an opportunity of hearing on the existing record. Having regard to the age of the matter, the Banking Court shall endeavour to decide the suit within three (03) months from receipt of the record. There shall be no order as to costs.

JUDGE

     JUDGE

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Naveed PA