IN THE HIGH COURT OF SINDH AT KARACHI

 

 

I.A. No.20 OF 2002

[Bank Al-Flah Limited v. M/s. S. Essa & others]

 

 

PRESENT:

            Mr. Justice Arshad Hussain Khan

                                      Mr. Justice Amjad Ali Sahito       

 

 

Appellants                 :           Through M/s. Tariq Ahmed Memon and Abdul

Munnaf, Advocates.

 

Respondents             :           Nemo.

                                               

Date of hearing         :           02.11.2026

Date of order             :           11.11.2026

 

 

 

JUDGMENT

 

ARSHAD HUSSAIN KHAN J;                   This First Appeal under Section 22 of the Financial Institutions (Recovery of Finances) Ordinance, 2001 is directed against the judgment and decree dated 15.10.2001 passed by the learned Judge, Banking Court No.I, Karachi in Suit No. 227 of 1997, whereby the suit of the appellant, Bank Alfalah Limited, for recovery of Rs.1,354,857.38 was dismissed with no order as to costs.

2.                  Briefly, the facts giving rise to the present Appeal are that Respondent No.1, a partnership firm, of which Respondents Nos.2 and 3 are partners, availed a post-shipment export refinance facility of Rs.960,000 in May 1991 from Bank of Credit and Commerce International (Overseas) Limited (BCCI), the predecessor-in-interest of the Appellant-Bank, against export documents relating to goods shipped to Bangladesh under a letter of credit. In consideration thereof, Respondent No.1 executed the requisite finance documents, including an Agreement for Finance, Demand Promissory Note, Undertaking and Letter of Hypothecation. The export documents, including a bill of exchange for US$46,290, were forwarded to BCCI's Dacca Branch, where the bill was reportedly accepted for payment upon maturity. However, following the collapse of BCCI in July 1991, the export proceeds remained unrealised. The Appellant-Bank, claiming that the refinance facility remained outstanding despite demands, instituted the recovery suit against the Respondents jointly and severally. The Respondents contested the suit, principally asserting that the transaction involved negotiation/purchase of export bills, that they had fulfilled their contractual obligations by submitting the export documents, and that the Appellant-Bank could not recover the amount without producing or returning the original bill of exchange. Upon recording evidence, the learned Banking Court held, inter alia, that the Appellant-Bank had failed to make genuine efforts to recover the export proceeds or retrieve the original bill of exchange and that, in its absence, the amount advanced could not be recovered from the Respondents. Consequently, the suit was dismissed through the impugned judgment and decree, giving rise to the present Appeal.

3.         Learned counsel for the Appellant-Bank, while assailing the impugned judgment and decree, contends that the learned Banking Court failed to appreciate that the suit was founded upon the Agreement for Finance, Demand Promissory Note and Undertaking, under which the Respondents admittedly availed a post-shipment export refinance facility of Rs.960,000 and were obligated to repay the same with agreed markup. He submits that the transaction involved export refinance secured against export documents and not an outright purchase of foreign bills at a discounted price. The learned Banking Court, therefore, erred in making recovery conditional upon production of the original bill of exchange by relying upon an unreported judgment distinguishable on facts. He further submits that the export documents were forwarded for collection, not negotiation, and that under the applicable Uniform Rules for Collections, the Appellant acted merely as a collecting agent and was not responsible for non-payment by the importer or issuing bank. The Respondents' obligation to repay the finance remained independent of realization of the export proceeds. He maintains that the learned Banking Court overlooked the correspondence evidencing efforts to recover the proceeds, misconstrued the obligations under the Amalgamation Scheme, and failed to appreciate that the Respondents had neither repaid the finance nor established any adjustment or set-off, the latter plea having been abandoned during trial. Despite acknowledging the Respondents' repayment obligation under the Undertaking and Form 'E', the learned Banking Court dismissed the suit solely for non-production of the original bill of exchange. He, therefore, prays that the impugned judgment and decree be set aside and the suit be decreed as prayed, with costs.

4.         None is in attendance on behalf of the Respondents despite service of notice and repeated cautions issued on the previous three dates of hearing, i.e., 05.08.2026, 13.10.2026 and 27.10.2026. The record reflects that Mr. Hamza I. Ali, Advocate, initially filed his power on behalf of the Respondents but subsequently remained absent, whereafter direct notices were issued to the Respondents, without any response. Considering that the Appeal has been pending since 2002 and sufficient opportunities have already been afforded, we deem it appropriate to proceed with its hearing with the assistance of learned counsel for the Appellant and on the basis of the material available on record.

5.         We have heard learned counsel for the Appellant and examined the impugned judgment, pleadings, documentary evidence and material available on record. The foremost question requiring determination is whether the learned Banking Court was justified in dismissing the recovery suit for non-production of the original bill of exchange, notwithstanding the admitted disbursement of finance and the contractual obligations undertaken by the Respondents.

6.                  The record reflects that Respondent No.1 obtained finance of Rs.960,000 under the Export Finance Scheme of the State Bank of Pakistan. The Agreement for Financing dated 25.05.1991 expressly records that the Respondents sold goods to the Bank for Rs.960,000 and simultaneously repurchased the same for Rs.1,026,279, payable on or before 20.05.1992. The Undertaking under Part-I likewise acknowledges receipt of the financing amount and the obligation to pay the agreed buy-back price. Clause 5(e) of the Agreement specifically obligates the customer to pay the purchase price on its due date, while Clause 7 provides for its recovery upon demand in accordance with the contractual terms. These provisions establish a contractual liability arising from an agreement admittedly acted upon through disbursement of finance.

7.                  The learned Banking Court, while deciding Issues Nos.2 and 4, itself observed that the Respondents were bound under the Undertaking and Form 'E' to repay the amount received from the Bank. Nevertheless, it declined recovery solely because the original bill of exchange had not been produced, placing reliance upon the unreported judgment in United Bank Limited v. M/s. Azmat Trading Co. (Pvt.) Ltd. (Suit No.1701 of 1997). The reliance was misplaced. As reproduced in the impugned judgment, the cited case concerned purchase of bills of exchange at a discounted price, where the financing agreement had not been acted upon. The present transaction, however, involved an admittedly disbursed financing facility supported by an executed Agreement for Financing stipulating a definite buy-back price. The learned Banking Court failed to distinguish between enforcement of rights arising directly under a bill of exchange and recovery founded upon an independently executed and acted-upon financing agreement.

8.                  Clause 10 of the Undertaking provides that the export proceeds, upon realization or negotiation, would be appropriated towards adjustment of the Respondents' liability. It does not provide that mere shipment of goods, submission of export documents or acceptance of the bill of exchange would itself constitute repayment or discharge of the financing obligation. Similarly, the Letter of Hypothecation expressly contemplates bills held for collection under lien and preserves the Bank's rights in respect of advances made against such documents. Consequently, the forwarding of export documents to BCCI's Dacca Branch and acceptance of the bill for payment upon maturity could not, in the absence of actual realization or an agreed discharge, extinguish the Respondents' liability under the financing agreement.

9.                  The distinction between negotiation and collection of a bill of exchange is also material. In the former, the bank may acquire rights in the instrument upon giving value, whereas in the latter it ordinarily acts on behalf of the customer for realization of proceeds, subject to the governing instructions and contractual arrangements. The learned Banking Court did not determine the legal character of the transaction with reference to the complete financing documents, but proceeded on the premise that production of the original bill was indispensable in either eventuality. Such an approach overlooks the independent contractual basis of the suit. The original bill might have been necessary for enforcement of rights directly arising thereunder, but its non-production did not, by itself, bar recovery under the Agreement for Financing.

10.             As regards Additional Issue No.7, the learned Banking Court held that the Appellant had failed to make genuine efforts to recover the export proceeds or retrieve the bill of exchange, principally because no claim was lodged with the liquidators of BCCI's Dacca Branch and no proceedings were instituted against its successor bank. However, the correspondence exhibited as Ex.P/16 to Ex.P/40, concerning efforts for realization of the proceeds, was not adequately evaluated. The Amalgamation Scheme contemplated assistance to customers in realizing foreign documentary bills sent for collection, while Form 'E' also contained obligations concerning realization of export proceeds. These provisions required consideration in their proper contractual and regulatory context. Nevertheless, any alleged deficiency in the Bank's collection efforts could not automatically operate as discharge of the Respondents' financing liability unless a legally sustainable defence of adjustment, satisfaction or compensable loss attributable to the Bank was established. No such defence was proved or quantified.

11.             It is also significant that the Respondents did not press their pleas concerning execution of blank documents and abandonment or set-off, which were accordingly answered against them by the learned Banking Court. The admitted receipt of finance was thus not met by proof of repayment, adjustment or any other legally recognized discharge. The learned Banking Court's conclusion that the suit could not succeed without production of the original bill of exchange was, therefore, inconsistent with the contractual documents and the evidence available on record.

12.             As regards the quantum of liability, the Agreement for Financing expressly stipulates the buy-back price at Rs.1,026,279, payable on or before 20.05.1992. The said amount represents the agreed contractual consideration and is distinguishable from the larger amount claimed in the plaint, together with additional markup and liquidated damages. Although the Appellant claimed further amounts, its entitlement thereto required independent justification under the contractual terms, statement of account and applicable law. In the absence of sufficient material establishing the basis and computation of such additional claims, the decree cannot extend beyond the stipulated contractual amount, subject to adjustment of any payments or recoveries already made.

13.             In view of the foregoing discussion, we are of the considered opinion that the learned Banking Court failed to appreciate the true nature of the financing transaction and the contractual obligations arising therefrom. The admitted disbursement of finance, coupled with the express terms of the Agreement for Financing and Undertaking, established the Respondents' liability to pay the agreed buy-back price, whereas no repayment, adjustment or discharge of such liability was proved. The learned Banking Court, therefore, erred in dismissing the suit merely on account of non-production of the original bill of exchange. Consequently, the present Appeal is allowed and the impugned judgment and decree dated 15.10.2001 are set aside. The suit of the Appellant-Bank is decreed against the Respondents, jointly and severally, in the sum of Rs.1,026,279, being the agreed buy-back price under the Agreement for Financing dated 25.05.1991, subject to adjustment of any payments or recoveries already made. The remaining monetary claims, not having been independently established, are declined. There shall be no order as to costs.

14.             Decree be drawn accordingly.

 

JUDGE

JUDGE

 

 

 

Naveed PA