ORDER SHEET

IN THE HIGH COURT OF SINDH BENCH AT SUKKUR

Civil Misc. Appeal No.S-10 of 2014

 

Date

               Order with signature of Judge

 

 

                           1.      For orders on CMA No.745/2014

                           2.      For katcha peshi

                           3.      For orders on CMA No.746/2014

 

 

Date of hearing 20-11-2017

 

 

          12-09-2014

Muhammad Rafique Appellant in person

            Mr. Muhammad Aslam Jatoi, Assistant Attorney General

            a/w Muhammad Iqbal Arain Deputy Director FPSC Islamabad

                                                     

 

O R D E R

                           12-09-2014

                                                 

 MUHAMMAD FAISAL KAMAL ALAM, J.   This is an appeal filed against the order dated 25.11.2014 passed by respondent No.2, whereby the appellant’s candidature for the post of Assistant Draftsman (BS-18) was rejected, on the ground of lack of the evidence about the requisite experience. On 30.10.2017 a detailed order was passed by this Court, inter alia, in which respondents were directed to place on record the credential of those candidates who were appointed against the seats reserved for the other Provinces relating to the same post. The observation in the last order about, inter alia, legislative drafting/drafting of statutes, rules and notifications is of relevance.

2.         A close examination of the record produced today by the respondents and after hearing the parties at length, the following order is passed.

3.         Since the appellant undisputedly has passed his written test and also has requisite academic qualification, the peculiar facts and circumstances warrant and justify that he should be called for an interview/viva-voice.        The learned Assistant Attorney General alongwith Mr. Muhammad Iqbal Arain the Deputy Director of FPSC, have stated that in the interview the appellant has to file his documents and credential as mentioned in the subject Consolidated Advertisement No.10/2013. This being a uniform criteria, obviously appellant can not deviate from that. Hence, the appellant will be called for an interview by the respondents as per prescribed procedure and his case will be considered by applying the same criteria as was done in the case of other three candidates and particularly M/S Abid Ali and Chand Ashraf, hailing from KPK and Punjab respectively.

4.         Accordingly, the orders/decisions impugned, passed by Respondents (FPSC), are set aside and present appeal is disposed of in the above terms.

 

                                                                                                   JUDGE

 

Suleman Khan/PA